| 1911-1912: Unknown at this time |
| 1912-1913: Unknown at this time |
| 1913-1914: S.K. John C. Riley* |
| 1914-1915: S.K. James G. Moran* |
| 1915-1916: Unknown at this time |
| 1916-1917: S.K. Arthur E. Culver* |
| 1917-1918: Unknown at this time |
| 1918-1919: S.K. Arthur E. Culver* |
| 1919-1920: S.K. Vincent J. Scully* |
| 1920-1921: S.K. Vincent J. Scully* |
| 1921-1922: Unknown at this time |
| 1922-1923: Unknown at this time |
| 1923-1924: S.K. Michael Hunihan* |
| 1924-1925: S.K. Bernard G. McGrath* |
| 1925-1926: Unknown at this time |
| 1926-1927: S.K. Thomas F. Higgins* |
| 1927-1928: S.K. Harold F. Ryan* |
| 1928-1929: S.K. Frederick J. Hott* |
| 1929-1930: S.K. Arthur T. Gilhuly* |
| 1930-1931: S.K. Joseph G. Smith* |
| 1931-1932: S.K. Sarsfield P. O'Keefe* |
| 1932-1933: S.K. John B. Beegan* |
| 1933-1934: S.K. Charles A Poirot* |
| 1934-1935: S.K. Walter White* |
| 1935-1936: S.K. H.C. Hume* |
| 1936-1937: S.K. Frank Loughlin* |
| 1937-1938: S.K. John Dunn* |
| 1938-1939: S.K. Thomas C. Gammon* |
| 1939-1940: S.K. Leonard J. Gilhuly* |
| 1940-1941: S.K. Thomas C. Shanley* |
| 1941-1942: S.K. James J. Moran* |
| 1942-1943: S.K. Lloyd Chase* |
| 1943-1944: S.K. Edward J. McKeown* |
| 1944-1945: S.K. William J. Rose* |
| 1945-1946: S.K. Fred J. Hennig* |
| 1946-1947: S.K. Ronald R. Smith* |
| 1947-1948: S.K. Joseph F. Amrich* |
| 1948-1949: S.K. William Davenport* |
| 1949-1950: S.K. James Carroll* |
| 1950-1951: S.K. Frank Devlin |
| 1951-1952: S.K. Vousi V. Driscoll* |
| 1952-1953: S.K. Rollen G. Kenney* |
| 1953-1954: S.K. Vincent McGrane* |
| 1954-1955: S.K. Francis M. Gersz* |
| 1955-1956: S.K. Raymond W. Glennon* |
| 1956-1957: S.K. William B. Beale* |
| 1957-1958: S.K. Thomas L. Creed* |
| 1958-1959: S.K. John F. Clancy* |
| 1959-1960: S.K. John E. Rigley* |
| 1960-1961: S.K. Salvatore J. Alea* |
| 1961-1962: S.K. Francis J. Correia* |
| 1962-1963: S.K. Michael J. Riordan* |
| 1963-1964: S.K. Henry W. Kowalski* |
| 1964-1965: S.K. Daniel J. Cohoon* |
| 1965-1966: S.K. Alfred J. Danoski* |
| 1966-1967: S.K. William Clark* |
| 1967-1968: S.K. Salvatore DePalma* |
| 1968-1969: S.K. Harold Flynn* |
| 1969-1970: S.K. W. Vincent Barry* |
| 1970-1971: S.K. Vincent G. Russell* |
| 1971-1972: S.K. Daniel Raucci* |
| 1972-1973: S.K. Reinhold Hekeler* |
| 1973-1974: S.K. Charles Slavin* |
| 1974-1975: S.K. Joseph Bengivengo |
| 1975-1976: S.K. Joseph Roy* |
| 1976-1977: S.K. Daniel G. Monaco* |
| 1977-1978: S.K. Martin J. Ronan* |
| 1978-1979: S.K. Joseph Rogers* |
| 1979-1980: S.K. Francis S McCarthy* |
| 1980-1981: S.K. Dr. Gabriel Azzaro |
| 1981-1982: S.K. Eros Toni* |
| 1982-1983: S.K. Lester Burns |
| 1983-1984: S.K. Louis N. Migliore* |
| 1984-1985: S.K. Thomas Purcell* |
| 1985-1986: S.K. Edward Adamczyk* |
| 1986-1987: S.K. Charles P. Dacey, Jr.* |
| 1987-1988: S.K. William J. Giblin |
| 1988-1989: S.K. Leo Mauri* |
| 1989-1990: S.K. Thomas F. Maher, Jr. |
| 1990-1991: S.K. Louis P. Fusco* |
| 1991-1992: S.K. William F. Sullivan* |
| 1992-1993: S.K. Joseph L. Sabo, Jr.* |
| 1993-1994: S.K. John F. Hogan |
| 1994-1995: S.K. Frederick D. Gobern |
| 1995-1996: S.K. Gaetano T. Gagliardi |
| 1996-1997: S.K. Andrew R. Calabrese, Jr. |
| 1997-1998: S.K. Ronald Arthur Rogers |
| 1998-1999: S.K. Arthur E. Moan Jr.* |
| 1999-2000: S.K. James E. Carty II |
| 2000-2001: S.K. Charles S. Costanzo |
| 2001-2002: S.K. Steven M. Drozd |
| 2002-2003: S.K. Louis F. Brown |
| 2003-2004: S.K. Richard McMunn |
| 2004-2005: S.K. Lawrence W. Cramer |
| 2005-2006: S.K. Stephen Yatcko |
